The Illusion of Productivity: When Health Optimization Becomes a Distraction
If you ever want to see how quickly a good thing can become a distraction, look at health in 2025. We have trackers on our wrists, apps on our phones, micro-optimized meal plans, sleep scores, HRV dashboards, supplements for every hour of the day — and more podcasts than we can listen to about “what to try next.”
On two recent episodes of the Home of Healthspan podcast, I sat down with Michael Chernow of Kreatures of Habit and Ben Azadi. Both of these guys live and breathe health — the fasting windows, the cold plunges, the stacks of supplements. It was inspiring, but what struck me most was a simple, deeper question we circled back to every time: WHY?
Why are we doing all of this? Because at some point, you have to ask: is all this optimization helping us live better — or is it just another thing to track, measure, and stress over?
When “Better” Becomes Another Box to Check
It’s an easy trap to fall into. I’m guilty of it too. A new supplement promising better sleep? Add it to the stack. A new protocol for muscle recovery? Let’s go. A new tracker? Strap it on.
But somewhere along the line, “health” can start to feel like work — another project to manage. Another layer of “productivity.” The irony? All this busyness might just be pulling us away from the point of it all: actually feeling good and living our lives.
A recent Vox article called out a perfect example: sleep trackers and “sleep anxiety.” More people are waking up groggy, not because they slept poorly, but because their wearable said they did. They check their score first thing in the morning — and if it’s bad, they spend the day feeling worse. The data becomes the experience.
That’s not rest. That’s a report card.
Tools Are Not Good or Bad — They’re Tools
I’m not anti-tech. Wearables are neutral. So are supplements, apps, fancy beds, or ice baths. They’re not “good” or “bad” — they just are. They’re like smartphones or AI: in the right hands, they’re powerful. Used mindlessly, they can drain us.
The same goes for anything in life. Even water — our most basic need — can be deadly in excess. These tools only work if we remember they’re just that: tools. They’re meant to serve us, not the other way around.
The Productivity Trap — Health Edition
Greg McKeown’s Essentialism changed how I think about this. In work, there’s always more you could do — more meetings, more emails, more Slack messages. But just because you’re busy doesn’t mean you’re moving the needle.
The same is true in wellness. There’s always another thing you could add:
✔️ Another supplement
✔️ Another cold plunge
✔️ Another new training protocol
✔️ Another fasting tweak
But does it serve you? Does it get you closer to what you really want?
Sometimes, the time you’d spend on another biohack would be better spent on the basics: getting to bed earlier. Taking a nap instead of forcing a workout. Or — and here’s the radical part — skipping the gym for an unhurried dinner with the people you love.
What Actually Matters
Health metrics are not health itself. They’re proxies — signposts. They can help us see if we’re moving in the right direction, but they’re not the destination.
No one lies on their deathbed wishing their sleep score had been a little higher, or their macros a little tighter. They remember moments. Laughter. A sunrise walk. Sharing a meal they didn’t obsessively log.
It’s easy to forget: the reason we chase health is so we can live. Not just longer, but better.
Essentialism for Your Wellbeing
So what if we applied McKeown’s Essentialism to our health?
✅ Sleep well — consistently — instead of chasing hacks on no sleep.
✅ Train hard — but know when to rest.
✅ Eat nourishing food — but share meals without guilt when you want to.
✅ Track your data — but don’t let it dictate your day.
More is not always better. Sometimes, more is just… more.
My Own Reminder
This lesson hit me recently. After a minor surgery, my routines went out the window: no swimming, no lifting, not even my daily stretches. For two weeks, my health “routine” was just resting — and yes, I hated it. I worried I’d lose momentum. But I realized: pushing would’ve made it worse. Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is nothing at all.
My wearables didn’t matter. My metrics didn’t matter. What mattered was letting my body heal so I could get back to living the life I want — not just checking boxes for the sake of checking them.
Use the Tools — But Live the Life
Health tracking, new gadgets, wearables — they’re amazing when they remind us to take care of ourselves. They’re dangerous when they convince us to live for the numbers.
So here’s my gentle nudge — and the reminder I’m giving myself too:
- The data is helpful.
- The hacks can be powerful.
- But they’re never the point.
The point is energy. Capability. Freedom. Presence. Joy. Connection.
The point is living.
A Simple Question
If you ever feel caught in the swirl of health optimization, pause and ask: Is this serving me, or am I serving it?
Don’t trade real life for perfect metrics. Use the tools to build the life you want — then go live it, fully.









