Self-Service
Over dinner recently I got into a discussion with my friend, Will. He mentioned to me the difference between “service” and “pleasing.”
“A lot of times we think we are serving someone,” he explained, “when in reality we are just pleasing them.” This pleasing, he explained to me, can run completely counter to serving them. He illustrated this point with an example of a friend who might be an addict. Yes, if we give that person money so he can feed his addiction, that in the near term would make that person “happy.” We could tell ourselves we are serving that person since now they are happier thanks to our helping hand. The reality, however, would be less rosy. We would be pleasing that person in the short-term but doing them no real service in the longer run, and likely even harming them.
The distinction Will drew resonated with me. In a world in which we hail the servant leader, and commend service, it made me realize that we, and I, needed to dig deeper in assessing the motivations behind that service. Was my action driven by a meaningful impact on something or someone else, or was I rather more motivated by the feeling I would get from it? This could come from the commendation of others for my “selfless” act, or it could come from a more intrinsic feeling of accomplishment I might get for what I did. In either case, my driving motivation was not really serving others, but it was rather serving myself. In my mind I began to label this sort of “serving” as “self-service.”
This is not to say good deeds cannot come from less than pure motivations. I am in the process of working my way through Robert Caro’s masterpiece of history, The Years of Lyndon Johnson Series. In it the contradictions of the former President are clearly set out, and they raise questions about his motivations for shepherding through the most impactful civil rights legislation in the US after the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments. Yes, good came of his work. And yes, his motivations may have been more self-serving than might have been realized at the time. Should we care?
As individuals, whether or not we care about Johnson’s motivations, I would argue we should care about our own. Our life is not just the sum of the things we do. It is also a product of who we are, as well as why and how we do them while we are here. Given this opportunity, this single opportunity to live the life we are given, shouldn’t we all strive to do things well, and do them for the right reasons?
During the same event where I was speaking with Will, another theme kept coming up. That of “planting trees under whose the shade you will never sit.” To do things for which you will never get credit, to do things that will benefit people we will never know, and who will never know we existed, but to do them anyway because they are the right thing, that to me is the ultimate measure of serving.
With so many issues now before us, issues that may or may not impact us, but that will certainly impact generations to come, if the time was ever right for service, it must be now.









